Morrisons, which operates the Morrisons Daily store on Castle Drive in Dinas Powys, which also hosts a Post Office franchise, plans to close the store in early October.
Residents and Councillors have shown their disappointment in the news, with many turning to local Facebook groups.
Plaid Cymru Councillors on Dinas Powys Community Council have launched a petition against the closure, with almost 1,000 signatures gathered to date over a small number of events.
Malcolm Phillips is one of the Councillors leading on the petition, calling on Morrisons to reverse the decision.
"We've got a population of nearly 9,000 here in Dinas Powys, it's mixed age groups, but an elderly population that relies on the post office for paying bills and getting money. There are lots of people who are alarmed, anxious and concerned about how they'd continue to access services."
"The nearest Post Offices to here are Sully, Barry or Penarth, that's okay if they're mobile and they have some way of getting there, but we've got a very age profiled population that simply can't do that. Although we've got good public transport links, theres lot of anxiety and concern, that they're worried about."
Morrisons Plfc confirmed to Bro Radio that a proposed closure will take place in early October, not July as has been announced locally.
A Post Office spokesperson said: “Our retail partner, Morrisons have reviewed their Morrisons Daily store operations and, subject to colleague consultation, are proposing to close their store at Murch. Consequently, the Post Office branches at this location would also need to close. We fully recognise the inconvenience this will cause our customers who rely on our banking and parcel services in particular.
“Should the decision be confirmed that the store is closing, we will then provide any closure date for the Post Office at that location. We will soon advertise the vacancy for the branch on our runapostoffice.co.uk website.”

Former Holm View Leisure Centre could become education and community hub
ScoutsCymru members represent Wales at Royal Albert Hall Festival of Remembrance
Plans for indoor market at former Barry Wilko move forward
Police given additional powers to deal with anti-social behaviour in Barry
Senedd passes supplementary budget with £60m boost for additional learning needs
Future of planned festive events in question after criminal damage to Barry Town Hall
Consultation to open on plans for 35MW solar farm near Penarth
No Trains through the Vale of Glamorgan this Sunday
Police and Cardiff City launch operation to tackle matchday anti-social behaviour
Free leaf and fallen fruit collections return in the Vale
Barry retains Fairtrade Town status until 2029
£1m improvements planned for Pencoedtre Park as splashpad work set to begin
Plan submitted for new independent school on site of well-known charity farm
Is your hot water bottle safe?
Solicitor sentenced for defrauding Cancer Research UK
Cate is crowned champion!
WATCH: Winner of The Voice UK Cate McHugh duets with Sir Tom Jones
Barry filmmaker takes her documentary to the big screen in New York
Pupils leave their mark on new school at steel signing event
£3m refurbishment plans revealed for Cowbridge Town Hall